For growing café teams
What would this hire need to deliver?
Rather than guessing whether it's worth it, this works backwards from the cost: the minimum this role would need to bring in, so you can judge for yourself whether that's realistic.
One thing to check first: if this is simply replacing someone who's left, with the same role and hours, none of this really applies. This is for a genuinely new or additional role, not a like-for-like backfill.
Beyond that, this isn't a yes or no answer, and it's not about whether someone would be good at the job. It gives you a number to weigh against what you already know about your business. And not every hiring decision is purely about money. Sometimes the case is a day off for whoever's currently running everything, or having cover when someone's ill.
The numbers below are examples. Swap in your own.
The cost of the role
Whatever you're actually planning (full-time, part-time, a few extra shifts), put the real hours and rate in.
Weekly cost of this role
£0
Now: where does that extra capacity actually go?
What the extra capacity is for
Pick whichever one is actually true for you. Most hires are really about one of these two.
You're capped at peak times. More hands means more customers served without longer queues.
Minimum needed
—
Against your estimate
Add an estimate to compare.
Weekly cost vs. what your estimate would bring in
What the estimate brings in is what's left after ingredients.
This is one hire, one scenario.
It assumes the extra demand is genuinely there. It's not guaranteed just because there's capacity to serve it. And it's one way this role could pay for itself; a real hire is often a mix of both.
- No ramp-up time. A new hire isn't at full capacity from week one.
- No recruitment or training cost included.
- Doesn't capture non-financial reasons to hire: reducing burnout, succession, resilience if someone's off sick.
If that minimum feels realistic, this could pay for itself faster than expected. If it feels like a stretch, that's just as useful to know before committing to the cost.
Want to talk it through?
If you're weighing a hire, it helps to talk it through against the rest of the picture.
Talk through your numbersFigures are simplified estimates for illustration, based on the inputs given. This is not HR advice specific to your business. General information and illustrations only, not financial, tax, legal or accounting advice. Figures are estimates and ranges, not promises. For those questions, check with a qualified adviser.